Trains of Thought

In the States, train travel is sometimes disregarded as the slowest and most boring way of getting from one place to another. A traveler might, for example, board Amtrak's Empire Builder in Chicago with nothing to look forward to for the next thirty two hours but the prospect of staring out the window at the cold and frozen expanse that is North Dakota and Eastern Montana until they finally pull into Whitefish, Montana bleary-eyed and half mad from the whole mind-numbing experience. The urge to go to sleep and lie comatose for the duration of the ride outweighs the novelty of the situation by an order of magnitude. This was my opinion of train travel for years, and as such was not looking forward to the plethora of train trips, both long and short, that this adventure would entail.

Now at the halfway point in this journey, I realize my opinion of train travel had been tainted by my one experience on American trains (the terminally dull trek described above) and I must revise my opinions on the subject. Last weekend I had the opportunity to make my way down to Nottingham, England. While this trip could have been made in a fraction of the time had I chosen to travel by air, the cost would have been far outside my travel budget, and I had yet to use any of my fifteen travel days on my Britrail train pass for a recreational excursion, so I sat down and planned out the route I would need to take to get to Nottingham at a reasonable hour. It would be a six hour trip, and if I caught the 6:32 AM train from Dundee I could get there with only one transfer. The early morning departure and lengthy transit time were unexpected, but I reminded myself that this was really the only way I would be able to go anywhere outside Dundee, and so gritted my teeth and committed to the early morning call at Dundee station.

The morning of my departure, I was struck with all manner of concerns: What if I miss the train? What if my pass doesn't work? How can I sit still for six hours? Fortunately, these worries evaporated as soon as I boarded the train and staked a claim on a window seat. As the train pulled away from the platform, I was suddenly struck by how ordinary this all seemed to the other passengers. Trains are not a novelty here; they are a way of life. To everyone else, this was ordinary. I calmed then, suddenly confident in their trust of this mode of travel, and settled in for the six hour ride. There were no snags, no confusing moments, and no delays. I arrived in Nottingham within a minute of the predicted time thinking how much more pleasant and relaxed the whole experience was compared to flying, or even driving my own car.

Why is train travel so commonplace here, while in the US it is often only a last resort? A large part of that, I think, is the distances involved. even the longest train route in the UK travels less than seven hundred miles- a long trip to be sure, but nowhere near the distances spanned by American railways. Air travel is so much more convenient over those distances that trains seem irrelevant by comparison. In addition, US railways have a poor reputation for reliability, which further lowers the opinions of many travelers. Trains were an important part of American culture, but as soon as something better came along, they were abandoned. However in the UK, and Scotland in particular, the railways are still embedded in the minds of the people as part of a national identity. Consider, for example, the city of Edinburgh's efforts to bridge the Firth of Forth. What started as a simple ferry system 900 years ago has become two (soon to be three) bridges that stand as a reminder of the times in which they were built, and the oldest of these is the Forth Bridge, an enormous cantilever rail bridge straight out of the height of the industrial revolution. This bridge has stood as a gateway to the north for nearly 125 years, and will continue to stand for the foreseeable future. It is a testament to both Scottish engineering and the importance of the railways that the first steel bridge in the world was constructed here so as to allow trains better access to the northern parts of the country, and that it still stands strong today.